Central Asia's French Revolution
Kyrgyzstan’s political tensions had been rising long before the riots that were broadcast all over the world and across Central Asia news stations, showing images of an angry mod swarming the street, and the dramatic moment at which a van was sent crashing through the ornate main gates of the Presidential Palace.
While President Bakiyev was forced to flee his capital, and ultimately the country, the reactions of Central Asian countries surrounding Kyrgyzstan have said much about the politics and human rights record of the region, when referring to the region it is taken for the purposes of this article to constitute Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan.
Central Africa is one of the most impoverished regions of the world, with a GDP per capita of just $2700. Poverty makes authoritarian leadership easy, as if the population is more concerned with surviving than politics, the leadership won’t have to be too concerned about sticky issues like human rights, with which Central Asia has a poor record.
It the Soviet legacy of this region that holds it back from true democracy. Autocratic models of leadership and politics were cemented here by the USSR when it annexed almost the entire region, and these have been difficult to shake off.
So far, Uzbekistan is only country out of the five former Soviet states to make anything akin to progress, and even then it still has an executive branch with a vast degree of power – parliament does not even have the authority to propose or draft legislation.
The reactions of the leaders of these countries to the crisis were telling then, in some cases they refused to acknowledge it. Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan have isolated themselves from the political upheaval in Kyrgyzstan, and images of democracy at work on TV, by not speaking about it at all, and preventing their state-run televisions from reporting on it in any depth.
Kazakhstan, on the other hand, a regional powerhouse with a vested interest in the stability of region, put pressure on the interim government in Kyrgyzstan to restore order so that continued acknowledgement of the near-revolution would not be necessary, and so that opposition forces in Kazakhstan couldn’t get any ideas in their heads.
At the same time, it issued a thinly veiled warning to the population of Kyrgyzstan, advising them not to put their hard-won freedoms and relative economic prosperity at risk. As a regional power, Kazakhstan has the power to take this away.
Tajikistan in the meantime could only watch what was occurring and wring its hands, offering sympathy to the people of Kyrgyzstan, while calling, rather softly, for a return to order. Tajikistan is the poorest, and therefore weakest, of the former Soviet countries in Central Asia, and has little clout when it comes to regional politics.
The diversity of these reactions supports what one commentator, Aitolkyn Kourmanova, has said, "The region is different in the level of political freedoms and liberal movements." It is not just a homogenous territory, which is what foreigners often think because of the commonality of “stan” on the end of each country’s name.
Aitolkyn Kourmanova is the executive director of the Institute for Economic Strategies of Central Asia, she told Central Asia news media that the differences in reaction reflect the differences in levels of political freedoms.
Kazakhstan has made some progress toward functional democracy, and so it was able to offer its ‘soft’ power approach, calling for calm, issuing veiled warnings while expressing sympathy for the people of Kyrgyzstan and brokering a peace deal at the same time so that the ousted president could be removed from the country in order to calm the waters.
Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan used ‘hard’ power, warning any would-be protestors that they would be met with the full force of the law, or what might otherwise be called brute force.
The political crisis in Kyrgyzstan was a nightmare scenario for the leaders of these countries, who have made little progress in political reform, and show little interest in stepping up the pace.
There was a time, a few days around the middle of April, when it seemed the ‘power of the people’ might spill over into neighboring countries with emotive force, but it now seems to have all calmed down.
The region can return to the status quo. Until the next time the people are pushed too far, that is.
Comments
More Central Asia News
RSS-
Moderate earthquake hits Tajikistan
DUSHANBE, May 25 (Itar-Tass) - A magnitude 5.6 earthquake rocked Tajikistan overnight to Saturday, the Geophysical Service of the Tajik Academy of Sciences told ...
-
PACE president to visit Azerbaijan
President of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Jean-Claude Mignon will visit Azerbaijan. During the visit, the PACE president will hold a number of meetings with the officials of the Parliament of Azerbaijan and Ministry of Foreign ...
-
Azerbaijan NATO PA discuss development of cooperation
Chairman of the Milli Majlis, Azerbaijan`s Parliament, Ogtay Asadov has met NATO Parliamentary Assembly president Hugh Bayley, who attends the Annual Conference of Parliamentary Network on the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund in Baku. Asadov said Azerbaijan pays special attention to developing ties with ...
-
Kyrgyzstan still coping with ethnic crises
There's a space for democracy and freedom of expression in Kyrgyzstan but there are underlying concerns about discrimination, a U.N. envoy said. Kyrgyzstan is struggling politically to evolve after ethnic violence followed a coup in 2010. The cities of Osh and Jalal Abab were the sites of violence between ethnic Uzbek and Kyrgyz communities after the coup. At least 400 people were killed ...
-
Azerbaijan can at any time revise its priorities – official
Azerbaijan, in accordance with the national interest, can at any time revise its priorities, and the crucial element here will be the issues of security. This was stated by head of the department of social and political issues of the Presidential Administration of Azerbaijan Ali Hasanov. "Everything is based on national, energy, political and social interests of Azerbaijan," he ...
-
All school leavers to be issued certificates in Azerbaijan
"Supporting the initiative of the Education Ministry, President Ilham Aliyev once again showed that he is the president of each Azerbaijani citizen and supporter of equal opportunities for every school leaver," Education Minister of Azerbaijan Mikayil Jabbarov said. In response to education minister’s appeal to the president, the latter ordered to issue certificates to all ...
-
Aypara mugam trio to perform in Tajikistan
At the invitation of Azerbaijani Ambassador to Tajikistan Abbasali Hasanov, a group of art figures are in Dushanbe on the occasion of 28 May - The Republic Day. A solo concert will be held on 24 and 27 May on this occasion, Aypara mugam trio told Mugam Radio. The concert will feature khananda Aytan Maharramova, Vugar Musayev, tar player Adalat Behbudov and kamancha player Parviz ...
-
Azerbaijan one of first countries receiving state support to host Euro-2020
London is hosting the 37th Ordinary UEFA Congress in which Azerbaijan is represented by AFFA General Secretary Elkhan Mammadov. During the visit to the British capital, Mammadov met with UEFA Secretary General Gianni Infantino and Director of the Committee of National Associations Theodore Teodoris, 1news.az reports citing the website of AFFA. On the instructions of AFFA President Rovnag ...
-
Festival Showcases Central Asian Films in New York
A festival of films from Central Asia, Turkey, and Central Europe was set to conclude in New York on May 24 with the screening of the highly acclaimed Uzbek film "Parizod." ...
-
Fitch Downgrades Kazakhstans Alliance Bank to CCC
U.S. prime money market funds (MMFs) increased their exposure to eurozone banks in April. However, even at 15.1%, asset allocations to these institutions remain well below 2011 levels, according to Fitch ...
-
New Indonesian Central Bank Chief To Focus on Inflation Amid Political Pressure
Former Finance Minister Agus Martowardojo began a five-year term as Indonesia's central bank governor Friday, taking the reins as Southeast Asia's biggest economy faces the prospect of higher inflation and political uncertainty ahead of general elections scheduled for next year.Mr. Martowardojo's immediate priority will be maintaining price stability as the government prepares to ...
-
Azerbaijan Will Not Join NATO CSTO Says Aide
BAKU, May 24 (RIA Novosti) - Azerbaijan will join neither NATO nor the Russia-led Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), but is prepared to cooperate with both, a presidential aide said on Friday. "As Azerbaijan has been participating in NATO’s Partnership for Peace program since 1995 we envision our future security model within the framework of the Nonaligned ...
-
Asia stocks erratic Europe shares steady day after global selloff
BANGKOK - Asian shares traded erratically Friday but European markets found their footing, a day after global stocks were routed by unexpectedly weak Chinese manufacturing and fears the Federal Reserve will start withdrawing its monetary stimulus. Japan's Nikkei 225 index, which plummeted more than 7 per cent Thursday, posted a big morning gain and then took investors on a dizzying ride ...
-
YARAT promotes Azerbaijan at Venice Biennale
Space of contemporary art YARAT! takes part in the Venice Biennale with exhibition - Love Me, Love Me Not. Love Me, Love Me Not is a unique exhibition of contemporary fine art in Azerbaijan and a number of neighbouring countries, featuring works by 17 artists from Azerbaijan, Iran, Turkey, Russia and Georgia. The exhibition, produced by a non-profit organization YARAT! (curator is Dina ...
-
95th anniversary of Azerbaijan Democratic Republic marked in Washington
Azerbaijani embassy in the United States has organized a reception in Washington to mark 95th anniversary of the Azerbaijan Democratic Republic. The event brought together high-ranking officials from the US presidential office, a number of Congress members, representatives of the US army, diplomatic missions accredited in the US including those belonging to Azerbaijan, Turkey and also Jewish ...
-
Azerbaijans transport sector not facing problems with investment support
The high credit rating allows international investors to trust Azerbaijan, easily issuing loans for the development of different major projects, including in transport. The statement came from head of the transport ministry's board of Azerbaijan Javid Najafov as part of the International Transport Forum in ...
-
Large families to be provided with apartments in Azerbaijan
The families in Azerbaijan with three and more children will be provided with apartments as well as special mortgage preferences. Chief of the department for social support policy of the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection Elnur Sultanov told APA that this is fixed in a new, special bill 'On provision of state support to large families' developed by the Presidential Administration ...
-
The United States and Azerbaijan have built a vibrant partnership - John Kerry
US Secretary of State John Kerry congratulates Azerbaijani people on the occasion of 28 May - the Republic Day. 'I am delighted to congratulate the people of Azerbaijan as you observe Republic Day this May 28. The United States and Azerbaijan have built a vibrant partnership, and we are committed to help buttress Azerbaijan’s independence, strengthening its democratic institutions ...
-
Mongolias long-awaited securities law paves way for giant mine
finally passed a long-awaited securities law on Friday that will allow the state-owned firm mining the enormous Tavan Tolgoi coal deposit to launch a $3 billion initial public offering at home and ...
-
Tajik airliner makes emergency landing at Khudzhand
DUSHANBE, May 24 (Itar-Tass) - A Boeing passenger plane of the Tajik Air national airline has made an emergency landing at the airport of destination in the Tajik city of Khudzhand, an airline source has told Tass. None of the 89 passengers and crew on board were injured, he ...
-
EM ASIA FX-Short-covering supports Asia FX but sentiment fragile
* Taiwan dlr up on exporters; intervention caps - traders * Philippine peso, won gains on short-covering (Adds text, updates prices) By Jongwoo Cheon SEOUL, May 24 (Reuters) - Most emerging currencies rebounded on Friday on pre-weekend short-covering in choppy trading, but investors hesitated to chase regional units due to shaky Japanese financial markets and ...
-
Asia stocks extend losses after big sell-off
View Photo A man walks past an electronic stock indicator showing the Nikkei 225 index which nosedived 1,143.28 points, or 7.3 percent to close at 14,483.98 in Tokyo Thursday, May 23, 2013. Japanese stocks plummeted Thursday after a spike in government bond yields and unexpectedly weak Chinese manufacturing spooked investors sitting atop months of massive gains in share prices. (AP Photo/Shizuo ...
Central Asia Discussion
-
Central Asia's French Revolution
The crisis that recently gripped Kyrgyzstan and saw President Bakiyev forced from power represents, for Central Asian countries, something similar to what the French Revolution represented to the aristocracy of Europe – that the masses are gathering and uniting.
Kyrgyzstan’s political tensions had been rising long before the riots that were broadcast all over the world and across Central Asia news stations, showing images of an angry mod swarming the street, and the dramatic moment at which a van was sent crashing through the ornate main gates of the Presidential Palace. Read more
News from around our Network
